Enron Mail

From:susan.scott@enron.com
To:bcherry@sempra.com, llorenz@socalgas.com, gsullivan@sempra.com,jsuwara@sempra.com, abb@eslawfirm.com, agenergy@aeca.com, agoldberg@lgl.twc.com, alexanms@sce.com, paulamirault@aec.ca, anchau@shellus.com, aod@newsdata.com, athomas@newenergy.com, awatt
Subject:GIR settlement discussions -- Transwestern Pipeline Company's
Cc:
Bcc:
Date:Mon, 14 Feb 2000 07:10:00 -0800 (PST)

Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
X-From: Susan Scott
X-To: "Cherry, Brian - TPBKC" <BCherry@sempra.com<, "Lorenz, Lad - TPLPL" <LLorenz@socalgas.com<, "Sullivan, Glen J." <GSullivan@sempra.com<, "Suwara, J.- TPJUS" <JSuwara@sempra.com<, abb@eslawfirm.com, agenergy@aeca.com, agoldberg@lgl.twc.com, "Alexander, Michael@sce" <alexanms@sce.com<, "Amirault, Paul@AEC" <paulamirault@aec.ca<, anchau@shellus.com, aod@newsdata.com, athomas@newenergy.com, awattslaw@earthlink.net, awodtke@aandellp.com, "Baldwin, Mark@IGS" <mbaldwin@igservice.com<, bbrunel@SMUD.org, "Bellenger, Geoffrey@PGE" <gjb2@pge.com<, "Black, Larry@SWG" <llblack@ibm.net<, "Blue, Greg@Dynegy" <gtbl@dynegy.com<, bmcc@mccarthylaw.com, "Bosley, Kirby@Reliant" <kbosley@reliantenergy.com<, bradylaw@pacbell.net, "Brown, Keith@SWG" <keith.brown@swgas.com<, "Brown, Sam@SW" <sam.brown@swgas.com<, "Brown, William@SWG" <william.brown@swgas.com<, "Burkholder, John@cts/whb" <burkee@cts.com<, "Bushman, Tom@CellNet" <tbushman@cellnet.com<, cbaker@ns.net, "Cervin, Peter@BR" <pcervin@br-inc.com<, cgoodman@bellatlantic.net, "Chancellor, Craig@Calpine" <craigc@calpine.com<, charles_doering@rmiinc.com, "Checketts, Bob@KR" <robert.s.checketts@wgp.twc.com<, "Cluff, Drew@Duke" <dacluff@duke-energy.com<, cmkehrein@ems-ca.com, "Collette, Martin@Econone" <mcollette@econone.com<, "Connell, Bruce@Conoco" <bruce.a.connell@usa.conoco.com<, "Cotroneo, Eileen@PGE" <efm2@pge.com<, "Counihan, Rick@Green Mountain" <rick.counihan@greenmountain.com<, "Cushnie, Colin@SCE" <cushnice@sce.com<, cyowell@ziagroup.com, "Dahlberg, Lynn@KR" <lynn.g.dahlberg@wgp.twc.com<, "Dasovich, Jeff@Enron" <jdasovic@enron.com<, "Davis, John@KR" <john.b.davis@wgp.twc.com<, "Day, Michael@GMSSR" <mday@gmssr.com<, "Dickinson, Sandy@PGE" <slda@pge.com<, difellman@earthlink.net, douglass@arterhadden.com, dsloan@pge-nw.com, ecrem@ix.netcom.com, ehahn@spurr.org, "Eisenman, Eric@PGE" <exe3@pge.com<, eklinkner@ci.pasadena.ca.us, "Elsesser, Evelyn@IP" <eke@aelaw.com<, epoole@adplaw.com, eric@gcnet.org, ewo@jmbm.com, "Fawcett, Jeff@Enron" <jeffery_fawcett@enron.com<, fergusonM@epenergy.com, fogelmanm@steefel.com, "Folsom, Bruce@Avista" <bfolsom@avistacorp.com<, "Foss, Rob@Coral Energy" <rfoss@coral-energy.com<, frazier@bull.som.yale.edu, "Frost, Pete@Conoco" <pete.frost@usa.conoco.com<, "Fullerton, Mark@WHP" <mafullerton@westernhubs.com<, "Gaillard, Bruno@Enron" <bgaillar@enron.com<, ghinners@reliantenergy.com, "Golden, Patrick@PGE" <pgg4@pge.com<, gpickering@idahopower.com, "Graham, Roger@PGE" <rag5@pge.com<, grant_kolling@cerberus.city.palo-alto.ca.us, "Hall, Rich@IGS" <rhall@igservice.com<, "Hannah, Jim@TXU" <jhannah@txuenergy.com<, "Harris, Mike@Reed" <mharris@rcgroup.com<, "Harris, Steve@TW" <sharris1@enron.com<, "Hawiger, Marcel@TURN" <marcel@turn.org<, "Healy, Bill@EPNG" <healyb@epenergy.com<, "Hensman, Kevan@Aera" <kbhensman@aeraenergy.com<, "Hilen, Christopher@Reliant" <chilen@llgm.com<, "Hoglund, Patrick@PGE" <pehb@pge.com<, "Honeycutt, Bedellia@REMAC" <honeycutt_bedelia@lacoe.edu<, "Huertas, A.@Enron" <ahuertas@enron.co.uk<, inggm@sce.com, jbennett@gmssr.com, jgopal@energy.state.ca.us, "Jimison, John" <johnj@bcjlaw.com<, jmct@gmssr.com, jmpa@dynegy.com, john.walley@swgas.com, "Johnson, Kirk@PGE" <mkj2@pge.com<, "Johnson, Pamela@REMAC" <johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu<, jond@qstr.com, "Jordan, Richard@SWG" <richard.jordan@swgas.com<, jsqueri@gmssr.com, jthomson@penn.com, jurewijl@sce.com, "Karp, Joseph@Whitecase" <karpjos@sf.whitecase.com<, "Katz, Stefanie@SET" <skatz@sempratrading.com<, "Kebler, Curtis@Reliant" <curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com<, "Keeler, Paul@BR" <pkeeler@br-inc.com<, keith-sappenfield@hlp.com, keith-sappenfield@reliantenergy.com, kirk.t.morgan@wgp.twc.com, "Klatt, Gregory@SCGC" <gklatt@jonesday.com<, kmills@cfbf.com, "Kramer, Daniel@CIPA" <dpk@cipa.org<, kschellin@mtpower.com, "Larmour, Jack@Dynegy" <jhla@dynegy.com<, "Latterel, Maria@PGE" <mpe1@pge.com<, "Ledene, Ben@WGS" <benledene@aec.ca<, "Leslie, John@Luce" <jleslie@luce.com<, "Lindh, Karen@CIG/CMA" <karen@klindh.com<, "Lins, Steve@Glendale" <slins@ci.glendale.ca.us<, "Litteneker, Randall@PGE" <rjl9@pge.com<, "Lizak, Greg@Itron" <greg.lizak@itron.com<, "Louttit, Craig@PGE" <cjl0@pge.com<, "Maan, Raveen@Cerberus" <raveen_maan@cerberus.city.palo-alto.ca.us<, malcantar@aandellp.com, "Masuda, Scott@LADWP" <smasud@ladwp.com<, "McClay, Shelley@Coral Energy" <smcclay@coral-energy.com<, mcclintocke@epenergy.com, "McConn, Kathy@EPNG" <mcconnk@epenergy.com<, "McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM" <kmccrea@sablaw.com<, mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com, "Meadows, Ted@UDS" <l97296@udscorp.com<, "Meadows, Ted@Ultramar" <ted_meadows@udscorp.com<, "Miller, Jerry@PGE" <grm8@pge.com<, "Miller, Preston@WGP" <preston.j.miller@wgp.twc.com<, "Moench, Mark@KR" <mark.c.moench@wgp.twc.com<, mtran@energy.state.ca.us, nge@value.net, "O'Donnell, Mike@PGE" <meo2@pge.com<, office@mccarthylaw.com, "O'Loughlin, Matthew@SCE" <moloughl@brattle.com<, "Orr, Carl@PGE" <cdo1@pge.com<, "Oshirock@pacbell.net" <oshirock@pacbell.net<, "Pate, Michael@OEM" <mike_pate@oxy.com<, paul.macavoy@yale.edu, "Pedersen, Norm@SCGC" <napedersen@jonesday.com<, "Pelote, Roger@Williams" <rpelote@energy.twc.com<, "Pettinato, Bob@LADWP" <rpetti@ladwp.com<, phanschen@gj.com, placourciere@sf.whitecase.com, "Pocino, Mark@RC" <mpocino@rcgroup.com<, "Pocta, Mark@ORA" <rmp@cpuc.ca.gov<, "Porter, Doug@SCE" <porterdk@sce.com<, "Power, Patrick@LB" <pjpowerlaw@aol.com<, "Radtke, Otto@CO" <oradtke@co.la.ca.us<, "Ramirez, Jaime@SWGas" <jaime.ramirez@swgas.com<, rbw@mrwassoc.com, "Reid, Al@PanCanadian" <alan_reid@pancanadian.ca<, rfigueroa@lif.org, rgloistein@orrick.com, rhc@mrwassoc.com, rliebert@cfbf.com, rmccann@cal.net, rnemec@mediaone.net, robertg@greenlining.org, "Rochman, Michael@CUB" <rochmanm@cubjpa.org<, "Rochman, Michael@SPURR" <rochmanm@spurr.org<, "Rosmon, Lewis@Tractebel" <lewisros@aol.com<, "Ross-Leech, Diane@PGE" <dpr5@pge.com<, "Rostker, Margaret@CCC" <rostkma@la.whitecase.com<, "Roth, Rosalie@Solutions" <rroth@sempra-slns.com<, "Roth, Tom@ET" <tom.roth@et.pge.com<, "rtask@norm.com" <rtask@noram.com<, salleyoo@dwt.com, scarter@nrdc.org, scohn@SMUD.org, "Shively, R.@Energynamics" <rshively@enerdynamics.com<, "Silva, Larry@Glendale" <lsilva@ci.glendale.ca.us<, simonsen@rmi.net, "Skaff, Andy@Dynegy" <askaff@chrm.com<, sneiman483@aol.com, "Soong, Gwen@IGS" <gsoong@igservice.com<, sscott3@enron.com, stomashe@energy.state.ca.us, "Stout, M.@sempra-slns" <mstout@sempra-slns.com<, "Sullivan, Catherine@Southernenergy" <catherine.sullivan@southernenergy.com<, "Sutton, J.C.@scana" <jcsutton@scana.com<, "Sweeney, Richard@CVernon" <rsweeney@ci.vernon.ca.us<, tbeach@vdn.com, thompson@wrightlaw.com, "Tisdale, Roger@Occidental" <Roger_Tisdale@oxy.com<, toca@compuserve.com, "tomb@crossborderenergy,com" <tomb@crossborderenergy.com<, tturner@ziagroup.com, vhconsult@earthlink.net, ward@phaser.com, "Weil, James@Aglet" <jweil@aglet.org<, "Wesson, Parks@Astra" <pwesson@earthlink.net<, whited@paceresources.com, "Wood, Bill@CEC" <bwood@energy.state.ca.us<, Wraff@adnc.com, "Wright, Elizabeth@LB" <elwrigh@ci.long-beach.ca.us<, "Yap, Cathy E." <ceyap@earthlink.net<, "Yu, Peter" <pyu@setrade.com<, "Zaiontz, Jean@BP" <zaiontj@bp.com<, "Zanaboni, Kathy@RES" <kzanaboni@reliantenergy.com<
X-cc:
X-bcc:
X-Folder: \Susan_Scott_Dec2000_June2001_1\Notes Folders\Discussion threads
X-Origin: SCOTT-S
X-FileName: sscott3.nsf

Parties represented at an informal meeting after the February 7, 2000
prehearing conference discussed circulating redlined versions of the CAC
settlement proposal as a point of departure for further settlement
conferences. Transwestern Pipeline Company submits the following comments in
lieu of a redlined document.

Transwestern fully supports the CAC's proposal of a path-defined receipt
point structure that would define primary and secondary rights at receipt
points on the SoCalGas system. Not only does the proposal satisfy the
Commission's requirement that Hector Road be established as a formal receipt
point, it is also consistent with open and non-discriminatory access and use
of the SoCalGas system, and will help provide a reasonable degree of
certainty so that all market participants can more effectively plan gas
transportation. CAC's proposed receipt point principles ensure that no
upstream transportation provider will unduly be denied access to SoCal's
system.

Transwestern believes that the parties may still need to address certain
details regarding implementation of the receipt point proposal that have not
been fully described in the CAC document. To this end, Transwestern proposes
that implementation of the receipt point proposal be included on the agenda
for the upcoming all-party settlement discussions. Transwestern looks
forward to a constructive discussion of the proposal and is confident that
the parties will be able to agree on a plan for implementation.

Susan Scott
Senior Counsel
Transwestern Pipeline Company
(713) 853-0596
sscott3@enron.com